The comparison between Haiti and El Salvador over the past decade highlights two divergent political and economic trajectories. While both countries showed similar economic growth rates of around 2.5% for the Haitian fiscal year 2016-2017, their paths gradually diverged starting from the fiscal year 2018-2019. El Salvador managed to regain notable economic growth momentum after the health and economic shock caused by the Covid-19 pandemic, while Haiti settled into a deep economic depression. This divergence is largely explained by fundamental differences in public security policy, governance, institutional stability, and the Haitian state's capacity to create an environment conducive to private investment.<\/p>
For Haiti, the challenge today is to break free from the vicious cycle of insecurity, political instability, and economic decline. It is not about mechanically replicating President Bukele's model, but about understanding the mechanisms that allowed this country to embark on an encouraging trajectory of economic growth. After eight years of economic contraction, Haiti cannot envision a genuine recovery without restoring the fundamental conditions for a true revival of economic activity: the security of people and property, state authority, institutional stability, and investor confidence.<\/p>
With a population of about 6.4 million inhabitants by 2026 (barely half of Haiti's population) spread over an area of 21,041 square kilometers (compared to 27,750 km² for Haiti), El Salvador experienced military dictatorship from December 2, 1931 to October 15, 1979, the Football War (July 14-18, 1969), and the Civil War from May 9, 1979 to January 16, 1992. The latter opposal the Farabundo Martí National Liberation Front (FMLN) and the then government represented by its army.<\/p>
2016-2018: A Country Confronted with Violence and Political Distrust<\/strong><\/p> Just ten years ago, El Salvador was among the most violent countries on the planet. In 2015, the homicide rate reached 106.8 per 100,000 inhabitants. Criminal gangs controlled a large part of economic activities, especially in the capital. Extortions, murders, forced displacements within the population, and the control of certain neighborhoods by criminal organizations constituted significant obstacles to economic growth. The same scenario has been observed in Haiti over the past five years. A decade later, the Salvadoran political and economic landscape has radically changed. The homicide rate dropped to 1.9 per 100,000 inhabitants in 2024, just five years after President Bukele took office on June 1, 2019. This profound transformation places El Salvador among the least affected countries by homicides in Latin America. It constitutes one of the most remarkable changes in recent Central American history.<\/p> In the mid-2010s, El Salvador was deeply impacted by the presence of two major criminal organizations, Mara Salvatrucha (MS-13) and Barrio 18. These gangs controlled territories, demanded ransoms from traders and transporters, and exerted pressure on local populations. Violence severely affected economic activity. Businesses had to deal with the costs associated with insecurity. Households lived in a climate of fear characterized by restrictions on their movements. For a part of the population, the weakness of institutions and the inability of successive governments to sustainably restore security fueled a deep distrust towards the traditional political class.<\/p> This atmosphere of distrust favored the emergence of a new political figure: Nayib Bukele. Former mayor of San Salvador, the capital of El Salvador, he gradually built his image in opposition to the two main political forces that had dominated political life since the end of the civil war: the Nationalist Republican Alliance (ARENA) and the Farabundo Martí National Liberation Front (FMLN).<\/p> 2019: The Arrival of Nayib Bukele to the Presidency and the Political Break<\/strong><\/p> The presidential election of February 2019 marked a decisive turning point in Salvadoran political life. Nayib Bukele won, at 37 years old, the election in the first round with about 53% of the votes, ending the dominance of the two traditional political parties. His rise to power is based on a discourse of breaking with old political practices, corruption, and the inefficiency of state institutions. He particularly promised to restore security, modernize public administration, and transform the country’s international image. His political communication, largely based on social media, helps reinforce his popularity. President Bukele develops a direct relationship with the population and presents his government as an alternative to traditional political elites. This strategy resonates strongly with a population that was weary of insecurity and economic hardships.<\/p> The legislative elections of February 2021 constituted another decisive step. Bukele's party, “Nuevas Ideas,” obtained a crushing majority in the Legislative Assembly. This victory gave him the means to deeply transform the institutions. On May 1, 2021, the new deputies dismissed the five magistrates of the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court as well as the Attorney General. These decisions, sharply criticized by several international organizations, marked a weakening of the institutional mechanisms that control the executive. But it was especially from March 2022 that the country experienced its most significant security transformation. Following a surge of violence perpetrated by armed gangs, the government declared a state of emergency. This allows for the extension of provisional detentions and the restriction of certain constitutional guarantees.<\/p> The authorities then launched a vast campaign of arrests against presumed members of criminal organizations. More than 90,000 people have been arrested under this policy, according to data reported by “Human Rights Watch” in 2025. The security results are undeniable. Homicides have drastically decreased, gangs have lost nearly all of their territorial control capacity, and the population has regained a freedom of movement that had been lost for years. In March 2026, the National Assembly approved a constitutional reform establishing life imprisonment for murderers, rapists, and terrorists.<\/p> The reduction in violence has substantially strengthened President Bukele's popularity. In February 2024, he was re-elected with approximately 84.7% of the votes cast. His party, “Nuevas Ideas,” obtained 54 of the 60 seats in the Legislative Assembly. This result reflects the support of a large part of the electorate for his security policy. It also indicates the weakening of the old political formations, ARENA and FMLN, which had shaped Salvadoran political life since the end of the civil war. However, it should be noted that this re-election occurred in a controversial constitutional context. The Constitution prohibited immediate presidential re-election, but an interpretation by the Constitutional Chamber, whose magistrates had been replaced in 2021, opened the way for Bukele's new candidacy. International observers also noted issues regarding the conditions for electoral competition.<\/p> In July 2025, the Legislative Assembly dominated by “Nuevas Ideas” adopted a constitutional reform allowing indefinite presidential re-election and extending the presidential term from five to six years. This institutional modification constitutes a further turning point in the evolution of the political regime. “Human Rights Watch” considers that these changes contribute to the concentration of power and the weakening of checks and balances. The question of the sustainability of democratic institutions thus becomes, for these organizations, one of the main concerns regarding the future of the country.<\/p> An Economy Revived, but Still Facing Structural Constraints<\/strong><\/p> The transformation of El Salvador is not limited to security and political institutions. The administration is also looking to reposition the country economically, notably by attracting investments, developing tourism, and modernizing infrastructures. For example, it attracted international attention with its policy in favor of Bitcoin, which became legal tender in September 2021. This initiative, presented as a means to promote financial inclusion and attract investments, made the country a lab for the use of cryptocurrencies in public policies. However, concerns about financial risks and transparency have led the IMF to call for tighter regulation of the state’s involvement in Bitcoin-related activities.<\/p> The regained security also serves as a tool for international repositioning. In this sense, the success of the Salvadoran mission in Haiti could be of great importance. For a long time, El Salvador was associated with gang violence and insecurity. This reputation constituted a major obstacle to tourism development. Today, the government seeks to transform this image by showcasing the Pacific beaches, the historical heritage of San Salvador, archaeological sites, and the country's natural landscapes. The development of tourism, particularly related to surfing, becomes an important avenue for economic diversification. Construction, infrastructures, and services also benefit from this new dynamic. However, the improvement of the security environment does not automatically guarantee an equitable redistribution of economic benefits. The quality of jobs, household incomes, access to public services, and territorial inequalities remain very significant issues.<\/p> The graph shows a striking contrast between the economic trajectories of Haiti and El Salvador over the past ten years. While Haiti's economic activity level has declined by about 14.8%, that of El Salvador has progressed by nearly 24.5% during this decade. This economic performance has been accompanied by a notable improvement in the living conditions of the Salvadoran population. Indeed, the poverty rate, which stood at 36.5% in 2016, decreased to 22.8% in 2023, before rising to 26.6% in 2025, according to data reported by Geo Factbook. Despite this increase, the poverty level remains nearly ten percentage points lower than in 2016.<\/p> This development illustrates the importance of economic growth in the fight against poverty and underscores the contrast between two economic trajectories. On one side, El Salvador, which has recorded an increase in economic activity and a substantial reduction in poverty during the period considered. On the other, Haiti, facing a prolonged economic contraction that further undermines household incomes and exacerbates social precariousness. President Bukele seems determined to help Haitian leaders turn the tide. However, the challenge will be to maintain this direction in the long term.<\/p> Thomas Lalime<\/p> thomaslalime@yahoo.fr<\/p>
<\/figure>






Commentaires
Aucun commentaire pour le moment. Soyez le premier à réagir.